All templates

Agency Selection Scorecard

0views
0uses
0likes

Report

What this template is about

The Agency Selection Scorecard is a step-by-step board for choosing an agency as a team. It walks you through six stages in one session: defining the project, setting weighted criteria, building a shortlist, scoring each agency, comparing the finalists, and recording the decision.

What it helps you achieve

Agency decisions often come down to the best pitch or the lowest price. This board gives you a structured, fair way to decide. By the end you will have:

  • A shared definition of the project, budget and deal-breakers

  • Scoring criteria weighted by what matters most to your team

  • A side-by-side scored comparison of up to five agencies

  • A documented decision with clear reasons and next steps

Who benefits from it

Marketing leads, founders, product owners and procurement teams hiring a design, development, branding or marketing agency. It works for one decision maker and works best with three to six stakeholders. It is especially useful when stakeholders disagree, or when the choice has to be justified to leadership or finance.

How to use it

  1. Define your project: add sticky notes for goals, scope, budget, timeline, decision makers and deal-breakers.

  2. Set your criteria: review the eight suggested criteria, dot-vote on them, and assign weights that total 100%.

  3. Build your shortlist: fill in one card per agency with services, relevant work and reviews.

  4. Score the agencies: rate each agency from 1 to 5 on every criterion, then multiply by the weights to get a total.

  5. Compare and discuss: map the strengths, risks and open questions for your top two or three.

  6. Decide and next steps: record the chosen agency, the reasons, and who does what next.

Designrush

Digital PR Specialist @ DesignRush

I'm a Digital PR Specialist, focused on building strong media relationships, developing outreach strategies, and creating meaningful opportunities for brand exposure.


Categories

Similar templates